Website sponsored by Community Foundation Silicon Valley 2001

 

HOOSIERS ABOVE NATIONAL AVERAGE IN CIVIC INVOLVEMENT

[Community Highlights] [Success Stories] [Press Release]

Contact: Angela Miller, (317) 630-5200
Indiana Grantmakers Alliance

THE CENTER ON PHILANTHROPY AT INDIANA UNIVERSITY, THE INDIANA GRANTMAKERS ALLIANCE AND HARVARD UNIVERSITY RELEASE
'SOCIAL CAPITAL' SURVEY FINDINGS

Hoosiers are above the national average in several important measures of civic involvement, according to a groundbreaking new survey released today by the Center on Philanthropy at Indiana University, the Indiana Grantmakers Alliance and Harvard University.

In political participation, trust of fellow citizens, and involvement in informal social activities and religious activities, Indiana residents scored higher than Americans nationwide. Hoosiers were at or near the national average in measures of civic participation such as leadership in clubs and social groups, charitable giving and volunteering, and diversity of relationships with other people.

Taken together, the factors the survey measured, such as club membership, participation in public affairs, volunteerism, and personal interactions, are barometers of "social capital" - the networks of civic engagement, shared responsibility and trust within a community that form the basis for the community's health, vitality and success. High levels of civic engagement and social connection among members of communities help foster better education, safer streets, stronger economies, more effective government, and healthier and more prosperous lives.

Americans' connections with each other and with community institutions have seriously declined over the last half century, as Harvard Professor Robert D. Putnam first brought to light in his heralded 1995 Journal of Democracy article, "Bowling Alone." This shortage of civic involvement has critical implications for social well being. Without adequate supplies of social capital, social institutions falter and lose effectiveness.

To measure social capital in Indiana, the Indiana Grantmakers Alliance and the Center on Philanthropy participated in a study that surveyed 1,000 Hoosiers as part of a larger national project. The Indiana study was funded by Lilly Endowment Inc. through a grant to Harvard University. Dr. Wolfgang Bielefeld of the Center on Philanthropy and School of Public and Environmental Affairs analyzed the Indiana results and how they compare to national findings.

The largest-ever national random sample survey of Americans' civic engagement, conducted by Putnam, also was released today by Harvard and three dozen community foundations and other funders. It found that levels of civic engagement predict the quality of community life and residents' happiness far better than levels of community education or income.

Ten key facets of social capital that emerged from the Social Capital Community Benchmark Survey, and Indiana's standing on these measures, follow.

Trust
Social trust:
At the core of social capital is the question of whether one can trust other people. Generalized social trust is important in facilitating social interaction and accomplishing shared goals. Our first index of social trust combines measures of trust in neighbors, co-workers, shop clerks, other people in one's religious organization, local police, and finally "most people."


· Indiana scored higher than the nation, with more than 72% of Hoosiers indicating medium or high levels of general social trust, versus 65.6% of Americans overall.

Inter-racial trust: This measure looks at the extent to which different racial groups (e.g., whites, blacks, Hispanics, and Asians) trust one another and thus is one measure of the health of inter-racial relations in a community.
· 84% of Indiana residents exhibited medium or high levels of inter-racial trust, compared with 78.8% of all Americans.

Informal socializing: This measure examines the degree to which people invited friends to their homes, hung out with friends in a public place, socialized with co-workers outside of work, played cards or board games with others, and visited with relatives.
· Almost three-quarters (73.3%) of Indiana residents reported medium to high levels of informal socializing, compared with over two-thirds (66.7%) of all Americans.

Faith-based engagement: Religion is a large part of social capital and community connection in America. Roughly one-half of all American connectedness is religious or religiously affiliated. This measure looks at religious attendance and membership, participation in church activities other than services, participation in organizations affiliated with religion, giving to religious causes and volunteering at places of worship.
· Hoosiers reported slightly more engagement in faith-based activities than did the nation as a whole. Thirty-four percent of Hoosiers reported the highest levels of engagement compared to just over 32% of Americans overall, which is not a statistically significant difference.

Political participation
Conventional politics: One of the key measures for how engaged we are in communities is the extent to which we are involved politically. This measure looks at how many people in our communities are registered to vote, actually vote, express interest in politics, are knowledgeable about political affairs, and read the newspaper regularly.
· 65.3% of Indiana residents participate in conventional politics at medium to high levels versus 62.9% of the national sample.

Protest politics: The data in the survey indicate that many communities that exhibit low levels of participation in conventional/electoral ways nonetheless exhibit high levels of participation in protest forms. These may include taking part in marches, demonstrations, boycotts, and rallies, and participating in labor- or ethnically-related groups or in groups that take action for local reform.
· Hoosiers were slightly less likely (24.1%) to participate in high levels of protest politics than were Americans in general (27.1%), not a statistically significant difference.

Diversity of friendships: Equally important to levels of social trust is how diverse people's social networks are across different professions, economic levels, faiths, races, sexual orientations and levels of community leadership. These "bridging ties" are especially valuable in producing community solidarity and in forging consensus on how communities need to change or work together.
· Hoosiers reported having slightly (but not significantly) greater numbers of diverse relationships than did Americans in general. In Indiana, 52.8% of respondents reported having more than seven friends from among 11 diverse sample categories, versus 50.7% of Americans generally.

Civic leadership and Associational Involvement: Many people get involved by joining local groups involving issues and activities they care about, such as veterans groups, sports teams, or book clubs. We measured such engagement in two ways:

Civic Leadership: This is a composite measure both of how frequently respondents engaged in groups, clubs and local discussions of town or school affairs, and whether the respondent took a leadership role within these groups.
· Indiana residents displayed levels of civic leadership virtually on a par with the rest of the country. Slightly (but not statistically significantly) more Hoosiers (38.7%) indicated the lowest level of civic leadership than did other U.S. residents (37.8%).

Associational involvement: Respondents were asked about participation in the following types of groups: religiously affiliated organizations; sports clubs, leagues, or outdoor activities; youth organizations; parent associations or school support groups; veterans groups; neighborhood associations; seniors groups; charity or social welfare organizations; labor unions; professional, trade, farm or business associations; service or fraternal organizations; ethnic, nationality, or civil rights organizations; political groups; literary, art, or musical groups; hobby, investment, or garden clubs; self-help programs; groups that meet only over the Internet; and "other" groups.
· Hoosiers reported participating at rates comparable to those of Americans overall. Almost half of both Indiana and U.S. residents reported participating in three or more types of organizations mentioned above.

Giving and volunteering: One of the ways that Americans express their concern for others is through giving to charity or volunteering. People and communities who are generous with their money frequently also are generous with their time.
· There was no statistically significant difference between Hoosiers and Americans in general in this measure. Nearly 67% of U.S. respondents reported medium to high levels of giving and volunteering, while just over 65% of Indiana respondents reported the same levels.

Social Capital in Indiana - Community Foundations Take the Lead
Survey results give us a quantifiable description of social capital in Indiana, but they cannot give us a feel for the organizations and people working to improve Indiana communities and strengthen social capital. Community foundations - local philanthropic organizations governed by a cross-section of a community's leadership - are at the center of much of this work. In each of Indiana's 92 counties, community foundations generate and manage permanent local endowment funds, distribute grants, and mobilize leadership and organizational resources to address community needs and opportunities-in other words, build social capital.

Take, for example, the Dream Team in Howard County. Over 25 business, education, government and civic leaders, including the Howard County Community Foundation executive director Ron Harper, have met monthly for over a year to tackle issues ranging from economic development to education to building a sense of community. Their goal is to build a world-class community within the next generation.

Residents of Russellville, a small town just north of Greencastle, transformed a vacant school on the town's deserted main street into a vibrant community center with funding and expertise from the Putnam County Foundation. The center offers exercise equipment, family activities and meeting space for community groups, which is utilized daily. The center has energized Russellville residents who are once again excited about their community.

In Grant County, the community foundation is bringing together the local newspaper, businesses and the Chamber of Commerce to sponsor "Framework for Change" workshops and newspaper articles that examine which aspects of their community are working, and which need improvement, to find ways to make Grant County a better place to live.

Further Information
For more Indiana results including statistical information, the national press release, a list of the participating sponsors and communities, detailed survey information, or leads to local stories, go to www.ingrantmakers.org and click on "Are We Bowling Alone?" (documents will be posted on March 1, 2001; call for embargoed copies prior to March 1).

###